Head to head
The short answer
Shear if the timber has value or has to be placed somewhere specific.
If your work is feeding a chipper, building log decks and cleaning up after someone else has cut, buy the grab — it is the highest-utilisation attachment most contractors own.
Choose a forestry mulcher when stems, regrowth and woody residue must be reduced into a controlled residual layer. Choose a hydraulic mower for grass, weeds and light scrub where fast area coverage and a maintained finish matter more than destroying woody material. A mower is not a lighter, cheaper mulcher; it is a different rotor and duty cycle.
Read comparison →
Grind in place when access, spoil, buried assets and reinstatement make excavation expensive. Excavate when the ground is already being stripped, the root plate must be exposed, or the stump can be handled inside an existing earthworks and disposal stream. Compare the completed site, not the minutes spent at the stump.
Read comparison →
Use a grapple saw where the carrier can establish a stable working envelope and controlled sections can be cut, held and placed from the ground. Use climbers and cranes where canopy access, reach, rigging geometry, tree condition or site constraints sit outside that envelope. The methods overlap, but neither replaces the other across every tree.
Read comparison →
Choose a tree shear where the carrier can grip, cut and place repeat stems safely and downstream handling can absorb the output. Keep chainsaw felling where access, selectivity, terrain, retained vegetation or unusual stem form defeats the machine envelope. Judge both methods at the point where timber is safely landed and the work area is released.
Read comparison →You will not find brand-versus-brand shoot-outs here, because this site has not independently tested this equipment and pretending otherwise would be dishonest. What the manufacturer profiles do instead is set out each range’s published specification, what it suits, where it does not fit and what the parts situation looks like in Australia — which is the part of a brand decision that actually costs money.
You will also not find price comparisons, because attachment pricing moves with the exchange rate, specification, rotation options and the carrier bracket. The costs page covers what drives the number instead, which stays true for longer than a figure does.
